The Drawbacks of Prophecy in Guiding Mankind, A Critique of Islamic Doctrine of Prophethood

Hossein Atrak

doi:10.21580/teo.2022.33.1.11735

The Drawbacks of Prophecy in Guiding Mankind, A Critique of Islamic Doctrine of Prophethood

* - Associate Professor, University of Zanjan, Iran, Islamic Republic of

(*) Corresponding Author

DOI: 10.21580/teo.2022.33.1.11735

Supp. File(s):

Abstract
References
Licensing
How to cite

The belief in the prophethood and sending prophets by God to guide mankind is one of the common beliefs of divine religions. According to Islamic theologians, divine knowledge and wisdom necessitate the sending of prophets to guide mankind. This study aims to determine the logical challenges associated with this idea, and whether such a thing is expected from God taking into account His attributes. The drawbacks and challenges of prophecy in the guidance of mankind include the logical problem of miracles' indication of prophecy, the inconsistency of miracles with the claims of prophecy, the temporal and linguistic mismatch between prophets and humans, human fallibility, the prophet's interregnum in the world, the problem of exegesis of the scriptures, and the problem of multiplicity of religions and sects. On the contrary, it appears that All-wise God could have used better, simpler, and more effective ways to guide mankind, such as spiritual and instinctive guidance, direct guidance, the sending of a single eternal prophet, and angelic guidance. As a result of the numerous logical and practical flaws in the use of prophecy to guide mankind, the author believes that it seems unlikely and unacceptable that All-wise and All-knowing God has sent prophets for human guidance, and that another justification must be sought for prophecy.

Supplement Files

Keywords: Prophecy, Prophets, God, Miracle, Guidance.

Abu al-Ã¡Â¸Â¤asan Ã¡Â¸Â¤alabÃ„Â«. (1414 AH/1993). ÃŠÂ¾IshÃ„Ârat al-Sabaq. Qum: Al-Nashr al-Islami institute, first edition.
Abu al-Ã¡Â¸Â¤asan MÃ„ÂwirdÃ„Â«. (1409 AH/1988). ÃŠÂ¾AÃŠÂ¿lÃ„Âm al-Nubuwwa. Maktabatu al-HilÃ„Âl, first edition.
Abu al-Ã¡Â¸Â¤asan ShaÃŠÂ¿rÃ„ÂnÃ„Â«. (n.d.). SharÃ¡Â¸Â¥ FÃ„ÂrsÃ„Â« TajrÃ„Â«d al-ÃŠÂ¾IÃŠÂ¿tiqÃ„Âd. Tehran: IntishÃ„ÂrÃ„Ât IslÃ„ÂmÃ„Â«yyah.
ÃŠÂ¿Allama Ã¡Â¸Â¤illÃ„Â«. (1363 SH/1984). ÃŠÂ¿AnwÃ„Âr al-MalakÃ…Â«t fÃ„Â« SharÃ¡Â¸Â¥ al-YÃ„ÂqÃ…Â«t. Editor: MuÃ¡Â¸Â¥ammad NajmÃ„Â« ZanjÃ„ÂnÃ„Â«. Qum: Al-SharÃ„Â«f RaÃ¡Â¸ÂÃ„Â«, second edition.
Ã„Â€midÃ„Â«, Sayf Al-Din. (1423 AH/2002). AbkÃ„Âr Al-AfkÃ„Âr fÃ„Â« ÃŠÂ¾Ã…ÂªsÃ…Â«l Al-DÃ„Â«n. AÃ¡Â¸Â¥mad MuÃ¡Â¸Â¥ammad MihdÃ„Â«. Qahira: Dar al-Kutub.
Atrak, Ã¡Â¸Â¤ossein. (2018). Ã¢Â€ÂœA Study and Critique of the Ã‚Â«Tark-i AwlÃƒÂ Ã‚Â» Approach in Justifying Prophets' Lapses.Ã¢Â€Â The Journal of Philosophical -Theological Research (JPTR), 20 (2), No.76: 29-56. DOI: 10.22091/PFK.2018.2061.1641
Atrak, Ã¡Â¸Â¤ossein. (2020 a). Philosophy of Religion Research, 18 (1), No. 35: 217-239.
Atrak, Ã¡Â¸Â¤ossein. (2020 b). Ã¢Â€ÂœA Critical Studying of Implying the Verse Ã¢Â€ÂœAÃ¡Â¹ÂÃ„Â«ÃŠÂ¿Ã…Â«Ã¢Â€Â on Infallibility,Ã¢Â€Â Hekmat e MoÃ¢Â€Â˜Ã„ÂÃ¡Â¹Â£er, 11 (1): 1-20. DOI. 10.30465/cw.2020.5333.
Atrak, Ã¡Â¸Â¤ossein. (2021). Ã¢Â€ÂœA Critical Survey of the Implication of the Verse Ã¢Â€Â˜LÃ„Â YanÃ„ÂlÃ¢Â€Â™ on the ProphetsÃ¢Â€Â™ InfallibilityÃ¢Â€Â. Philosophical Meditations, 11 (1), No. 26: 193-222.
BÃ„ÂjÃ…Â«rÃ„Â«, IbrÃ„ÂhÃ„Â«m. (1431/2010). Ã¡Â¸Â¤Ã„ÂshÃ„Â«yat-u al-ÃŠÂ¾ImÃ„Âm BiyjÃ…Â«rÃ„Â« ÃŠÂ¿AlÃ„Â Juharihi al-TuÃ¡Â¸Â¥Ã„Â«d. QÃ„Âhira: DÃ„Âr al-.
FÃ„ÂÃ¡Â¸Âil MiqdÃ„Âd (1422 AH/2001). Al-LawÃ„ÂmiÃŠÂ¿-u al-IlÃ„ÂhÃ„Â«yya fi al-MabÃ„Âhith-i al-KalÃ„ÂmÃ„Â«yya. Qom: Daftar TabliqÃ„Ât Islami, second edition.
FÃ„ÂÃ¡Â¸Âil MiqdÃ„Âd. (1412 AH/1991). Al-ÃŠÂ¾IÃŠÂ¿timÃ„Âd fÃ„Â« SharÃ¡Â¸Â¥ WÃ„Âjib al-ÃŠÂ¾IÃŠÂ¿tiqÃ„Âd. Editor: Ã¡Â¸ÂŒÃ„Â«yÃ„ÂÃŠÂ¾al-DÃ„Â«n BaÃ¡Â¹Â£rÃ„Â«. Mashhad: MajmaÃŠÂ¿ al-BÃ…Â«Ã¡Â¸Â¥Ã…Â«th al-IslÃ„Âmiyya, first edition.
FÃ„ÂÃ¡Â¸Âil MiqdÃ„Âd. (1420 AH/1999). Al-ÃŠÂ¾AnwÃ„Âr al-JalÃ„ÂlÃ„Â«yya fÃ„Â« SharÃ¡Â¸Â¥ al-FuÃ¡Â¹Â£Ã…Â«l al-NaÃ¡Â¹Â£Ã„Â«rÃ„Â«yya. Editors: ÃŠÂ¿AlÃ„Â« Ã¡Â¸Â¤Ã„ÂjÃ„Â« Ã„Â€bÃ„ÂdÃ„Â« & ÃŠÂ¿AbbÃ„Âs JalÃ„ÂlÃ„Â« nÃ„Â«yÃ„Â. Mashhad: MajmaÃŠÂ¿ al-BÃ…Â«Ã¡Â¸Â¥Ã…Â«th al-IslÃ„Âmiyya, first edition.
Ibn TÃ„Â«mÃ„Â«yyih. (1425 AH/2004). SharÃ¡Â¸Â¥ al-ÃŠÂ¿AqÃ„Â«dat al-IsfahanÃ„Â«yyah. BiyrÃ…Â«t: Al-Maktabat al-ÃŠÂ¿AÃ¡Â¹Â£rÃ„Â«yyah, first edition.
ÃŠÂ¾IjÃ„Â«, ÃŠÂ¿AÃ¡Â¸Âud Al-DÃ„Â«n; JurjÃ„ÂnÃ„Â«, Ali ibn Muhammad. (1325 AH/1907). SharÃ¡Â¸Â¥ Al-MawÃ„Âqif. Editor: Badru al-DÃ„Â«n NaÃŠÂ¿Ã¡Â¹Â£Ã„ÂnÃ„Â«. Ufsit Qum: Al-SharÃ„Â«f RaÃ¡Â¸ÂÃ„Â«, first edition.
JuwiynÃ„Â«, ÃŠÂ¿Abdu al-Malik. (1416 AH/1995). Al-ÃŠÂ¾IrshÃ„Âd ÃŠÂ¾ilÃ„Â QawÃ„ÂÃ¡Â¹ÂiÃŠÂ¿ al-ÃŠÂ¾Adillat fÃ„Â« ÃŠÂ¾Awwal al-ÃŠÂ¾ItiqÃ„Âd. Beyrut: DÃ„Âr al-Kutub al-ÃŠÂ¾Ilmiyya, first edition.
MakÃ„Ârim ShÃ„Â«rÃ„ÂzÃ„Â«, NÃ„Âser. (1379 SH/2000). Al-Amthal fi TafsÃ„Â«r-i KÃ„Â«tÃ„Âb-i Al-Munzal. Qum: Madrasah Imam Ã¡Â¿Â¾AlÃ„Â« Ibn AbÃ„Â«tÃ„Âlib, first edition.
MuÃŠÂ¾ayyidÃ„Â«, IbrÃ„ÂhÃ„Â«m ibn Muhammad ibn AÃ¡Â¸Â¥mad. (1422 AH/2001). Al-ÃŠÂ¾IÃ¡Â¹Â£bÃ„ÂÃ¡Â¸Â¥ ÃŠÂ¿ala Al-MiÃ¡Â¹Â£bÃ„ÂÃ¡Â¸Â¥ fÃ„Â« MaÃŠÂ¿rifat al-Malik al_FattÃ„ÂÃ¡Â¸Â¥. Ã¡Â¹Â¢anÃŠÂ¿Ã„Â: al-ImÃ„Âm Ziyd ibn ÃŠÂ¿AlÃ„Â« Institute.
MuÃ¡Â¸Â¥aqiq BaÃ¡Â¸Â¥rÃ„ÂnÃ„Â«, Ibn Miytham. (1406 AH/1985). QawÃ„ÂÃŠÂ¿id al-MarÃ„Âm fÃ„Â« ÃŠÂ¿Ilm al-KalÃ„Âm. Editor; Sayyid AÃ¡Â¸Â¥mad Ã¡Â¸Â¤ussiynÃ„Â«. Qum: Ã„Â€yatu Allah MarÃŠÂ¿ashÃ„Â« NajfÃ„Â«Ã¢Â€Â™s Library, second edition.
MusawÃ„Â«, Abd-u al-RahÃ„Â«m. (1426 AH/2005). Al-IÃ¡Â¹Â£mat-u fi al-Nabuwwat wa al-ImÃ„Âmat. In: FÃ„Â« RiÃ¡Â¸Â¥Ã„Âb-i Ahl-u al-Bayt, al-MajmaÃŠÂ¿ al-Ã„Â€lÃ„Âmi li Ahl al-Bayt, vol. 40, second edition.
MuÃ¡ÂºÂ“affar, MuÃ¡Â¸Â¥ammad Husiyn (1377 SH). DalÃ„ÂÃŠÂ¾il Al-Ã¡Â¹Â¢idq. Translation: Muhammad SipihrÃ„Â«. Tehran: Amir KabÃ„Â«r Press, first edition.
NarÃ„ÂqÃ„Â«, Mulla mahdÃ„Â«. (1369 SH/1990). ÃŠÂ¾AnÃ„Â«s al-MuwaÃ¡Â¸Â¥idÃ„Â«n. Editor: Ã„Â€yat Allah QÃ„ÂÃ¡Â¸ÂÃ„Â«. Tehran: al-ZahrÃ„Â, second edition.
QÃ„ÂÃ¡Â¸Âi ÃÂ‘AyÃ„ÂÃ¡Â¸Â (1407 AH/1986). Al-ShifÃ„Â bi TaÃÂ‘rÃ„Â«f-i HuqÃ…Â«q-u al-MustafÃ„Â. ÃŠÂ¿AmmÃ„Ân: DÃ„Âr-u al-FihÃ„Â, second edition.
QÃ„Âsim ibn MuÃ¡Â¸Â¥ammad ibn ÃŠÂ¿AlÃ„Â«. (1421 AH/2000). Al-ÃŠÂ¾AsÃ„Âs LiÃŠÂ¿aqÃ„Âid al-ÃŠÂ¾AkyÃ„Âs. Ã¡Â¹Â¢aÃŠÂ¿da: Maktabt al-TurÃ„Âth al-IslamÃ„Â«, third edition.
RÃ„ÂzÃ„Â« Ã¡Â¸Â¤anafÃ„Â«, AbÃ…Â«bakr AÃ¡Â¸Â¥mad. (1422 AH/2001). Sharh-u BidaÃŠÂ¾-u Al-ÃŠÂ¾AmÃ„ÂlÃ„Â«. Beirut: DÃ„Âr al-Kutub al-IlmÃ„Â«yya, first edition.
RÃ„ÂzÃ„Â«, Fakhr-u al-DÃ„Â«n. (1420 AH/1999). TafsÃ„Â«r-u MafÃ„ÂtÃ„Â«h-i al-Ghayb. Beirut: DÃ„Âr IhyÃ„ÂÃŠÂ¼ al-TurÃ„Âth al-ÃŠÂ¿Arabi, third edition.
RÃ„ÂzÃ„Â«, Fakhr-u al-DÃ„Â«n. (1986). Al-ÃŠÂ¾ArbaÃŠÂ¿Ã„Â«n fÃ„Â« ÃŠÂ¾UsÃ…Â«l al-DÃ„Â«n. QÃ„Âhira: Maktabat al-Kulliyyat al-Azhariyya, first edition.
SabziwÃ„ÂrÃ„Â«, QuÃ¡Â¹Âbu al-DÃ„Â«n. (1373 SH/1994). Al-KhulÃ„ÂÃ¡Â¹Â£at fÃ„Â« ÃŠÂ¿Ilm al-KalÃ„Âm. Editor: RasÃ…Â«l JaÃŠÂ¿farÃ„Â«yyÃ„Ân. Qum: Ã„Â€yatu Allah MarÃŠÂ¿ashÃ„Â« NajfÃ„Â«Ã¢Â€Â™s Library, first edition.
SaqqÃ„Âf, Ã¡Â¸Â¤asan ibn ÃŠÂ¿AlÃ„Â«. (1428/2007). SharÃ¡Â¸Â¥ Al-ÃŠÂ¿AqÃ„Â«dat-u Al-Ã¡Â¹Â¬aÃ¡Â¸Â¥Ã„ÂwÃ„Â«yya. BiyrÃ…Â«t: DÃ„Âr al-ÃŠÂ¾ImÃ„Âm al-RawÃ„Âs.
Sayyid MurtaÃ¡Â¸ÂÃ„Â (1250 SH/1871), TanzÃ„Â«h-u al-AnbÃ„Â«yÃ„Â. Qom: al-SharÃ„Â«f al- RÃ„ÂzÃ„Â«.
SharÃ„Â«f MurtaÃ¡Â¸ÂÃ„Â. (1411 AH/1990). Al-DhakhÃ„Â«ra fÃ„Â« ÃŠÂ¿Ilm al-KalÃ„Âm. Editor: Sayyid AÃ¡Â¸Â¥mad Ã¡Â¸Â¤ussiynÃ„Â«. Qum: al-Nashr al-Islami institute.
SubÃ¡Â¸Â¥Ã„ÂnÃ„Â«, JaÃŠÂ¿far. (1368 SH/1989). Al-ÃŠÂ¾Iqidat-u Al-ÃŠÂ¾IslÃ„Âmiyya. Qum: Daftar TablÃ„Â«ghÃ„Ât IslamÃ„Â«, third edition.
SubÃ¡Â¸Â¥Ã„ÂnÃ„Â«, JaÃŠÂ¿far. (1381 SH/2002). Al-ÃŠÂ¾InÃ¡Â¹Â£Ã„Âf fÃ„Â« MasÃ„ÂÃŠÂ¾il DÃ„Âma fÃ„Â«ha Al-KhilÃ„Âf. Qum: MuÃŠÂ¾asisyi Imam Ã¡Â¹Â¢Ã„Âdiq.
SubÃ¡Â¸Â¥Ã„ÂnÃ„Â«, JaÃŠÂ¿far. (n.d.). Silsilatu Al-MasÃ„ÂÃŠÂ¾il Al-ÃŠÂ¿AqÃ„ÂÃŠÂ¾idiyya. Qum: MuÃŠÂ¾asisyi Imam Ã¡Â¹Â¢Ã„Âdiq.
Ã¡Â¹Â¬abarsÃ„Â«, FaÃ¡Â¸Âl ibn Ã¡Â¸Â¤asan. (1408/1987). MajmaÃŠÂ¿ Al-BayÃ„Ân. BiyrÃ…Â«t: DÃ„Âr al-MaÃŠÂ¿rifat.
Ã¡Â¹Â¬abÃ„ÂÃ¡Â¹ÂabÃ„ÂÃŠÂ¾Ã„Â«. MuÃ¡Â¸Â¥ammad Ã¡Â¸Â¤ussiyn. (1378 SH/1999). TafsÃ„Â«r Al-MÃ„Â«zÃ„Ân. Translated by: MuÃ¡Â¸Â¥ammad BÃ„Âir MÃ…Â«sawÃ„Â«. Qum: Daftar IntishÃ„ÂrÃ„Ât IslÃ„ÂmÃ„Â«.
TaftÃ„ÂzÃ„ÂnÃ„Â«, SaÃŠÂ¿d al-DÃ„Â«n. (1409 AH/1988), SharÃ¡Â¸Â¥-u Al-MaqÃ„ÂÃ¡Â¹Â£id. Qom: al-SharÃ„Â«f al-RÃ„ÂzÃ„Â«, first edition.
TusÃ„Â«, KhÃ„Âji NaÃ¡Â¹Â£Ã„Â«r al-DÃ„Â«n. (1405 AH/1984). RasÃ„ÂÃŠÂ¾il KhÃ„Âji NaÃ¡Â¹Â£Ã„Â«r Al-DÃ„Â«n Ã¡Â¹Â¬usÃ„Â«. Beyrut: DÃ„Âr al-ÃŠÂ¾AÃ¡Â¸ÂwÃ„ÂÃŠÂ¾, second edition.
TusÃ„Â«, KhÃ„Âji NaÃ¡Â¹Â£Ã„Â«r al-DÃ„Â«n. (1407 AH/1986). TajrÃ„Â«d Al-ÃŠÂ¾IÃŠÂ¿tiqÃ„Âd. Editor: Ã¡Â¸Â¤usiynÃ„Â« JalÃ„ÂlÃ„Â«. Qum: Daftar TablÃ„Â«ghÃ„Ât IslamÃ„Â«, first edition.
Ã¡Â¹Â¬usÃ„Â«, NasÃ„Â«r al-DÃ„Â«n. (1405 AH/1984). TalkhÃ„Â«Ã¡Â¹Â£ al-MuhaÃ¡Â¹Â£Ã¡Â¹Â£al. BeirÃ…Â«t: DÃ„Âr al-AÃ¡Â¸ÂwÃ„ÂÃ¢Â€Â˜, second edition.